Тысячи расстрелянных священников в 1922-м? Хмуркин проверяет цифры по архивам | Колпакиди и Хмуркин

2026-10-10 · edited 2026-10-10

✓ Watched
▶ 00:00
⏹ 00:51
00:51
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:51
Введение: спорные страницы истории православия и СССР
✓ Watched
▶ 00:52
⏹ 01:48
00:56
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:56
Почему «чёрные страницы» стали чёрными после перестройки
✓ Watched
▶ 01:49
⏹ 02:46
00:57
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:57
Голод, церковь и контекст начала 1920-х
✓ Watched
▶ 02:47
⏹ 03:17
00:30
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:30
Отношение Ленина к вере и верующим
✓ Watched
▶ 03:18
⏹ 05:42
02:24
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 02:24
Анонс конференции «Феномен советского человека» (4–5 апреля)
✓ Watched
▶ 05:43
⏹ 08:22
02:39
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 02:39
Изъятие церковных ценностей и письмо Ленина от 19 марта 1922
✓ Watched
▶ 08:23
⏹ 12:51
04:28
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 04:28
Резкость Ленина и её реальный контекст
✓ Watched
▶ 12:52
⏹ 13:27
00:35
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:35
Экономическая катастрофа после гражданской войны
✓ Watched
▶ 13:28
⏹ 14:56
01:28
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:28
Засуха 1921 года и системные неурожаи
✓ Watched
▶ 14:57
⏹ 15:43
00:46
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:46
Прогноз Михельсона и реакция Ленина
✓ Watched
▶ 15:44
⏹ 21:29
05:45
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 05:45
Блок о защите памяти Ленина и борьбе с фальсификациями
✓ Watched
▶ 21:30
⏹ 23:20
01:50
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:50
Как советская власть готовилась к борьбе с голодом
✓ Watched
▶ 23:21
⏹ 24:34
01:13
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:13
Последствия голода: восстания и страх внутреннего хаоса
✓ Watched
▶ 24:35
⏹ 26:19
01:44
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:44
Золото, интервенция и нервозность руководства
✓ Watched
▶ 26:20
⏹ 29:01
02:41
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 02:41
Поиск золота и обсуждение изъятия ценностей
✓ Watched
▶ 29:02
⏹ 29:14
00:12
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:12
Решение об изъятии ценностей в начале 1922 года
✓ Watched
▶ 29:15
⏹ 31:43
02:28
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 02:28
Позиция патриарха Тихона
✓ Watched
▶ 31:44
⏹ 32:24
00:40
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:40
Декрет от 26 февраля 1922 и что именно изымалось
✓ Watched
▶ 32:25
⏹ 35:35
03:10
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 03:10
Реакция Тихона и конфликт вокруг святотатства
✓ Watched
▶ 35:36
⏹ 37:26
01:50
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:50
Позиция Троцкого и срочность кампании
✓ Watched
▶ 37:27
⏹ 39:19
01:52
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:52
Информационная политика большевиков
✓ Watched
▶ 39:20
⏹ 41:54
02:34
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 02:34
Шуя: столкновение, жертвы и информационная интерпретация
✓ Watched
▶ 41:55
⏹ 43:33
01:38
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:38
Реакция Ленина после Шуи
✓ Watched
▶ 43:34
⏹ 44:33
00:59
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:59
Декрет об отделении церкви от государства (1918) и первая реакция
✓ Watched
▶ 44:34
⏹ 45:33
00:59
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:59
Как происходила нормализация отношений
✓ Watched
▶ 45:34
⏹ 47:39
02:05
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 02:05
Адаптация церкви к новым условиям
✓ Watched
▶ 47:40
⏹ 49:09
01:29
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:29
Имущественные права церкви по декрету
✓ Watched
▶ 49:10
⏹ 51:09
01:59
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:59
«Двадцатки» и договоры с местной властью
✓ Watched
▶ 51:10
⏹ 52:09
00:59
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:59
Экономический удар по духовенству и новая бедность
✓ Watched
▶ 52:10
⏹ 53:02
00:52
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:52
Философский аспект: переосмысление церковного служения
✓ Watched
▶ 53:03
⏹ 54:03
01:00
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:00
Консенсус по вопросу церковного имущества
✓ Watched
▶ 54:04
⏹ 54:41
00:37
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:37
Письмо Ленина и его реальное влияние
✓ Watched
▶ 54:42
⏹ 57:14
02:32
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 02:32
Масштабы изъятия по регионам
✓ Watched
▶ 57:15
⏹ 58:49
01:34
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:34
Реакция населения и поддержка в голодающих районах
✓ Watched
▶ 58:50
⏹ 01:01:32
02:42
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 02:42
Архивы 1990-х и новые исследования
✓ Watched
▶ 01:01:33
⏹ 01:02:53
01:20
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:20
Региональные кейсы: где было спокойно, где — конфликты
✓ Watched
▶ 01:02:54
⏹ 01:04:23
01:29
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:29
Мирное сопротивление, аресты и суды
✓ Watched
▶ 01:04:24
⏹ 01:06:26
02:02
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 02:02
Суды 1922 года и миф о массовых расправах
✓ Watched
▶ 01:06:27
⏹ 01:08:22
01:55
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:55
Откуда взялись завышенные цифры жертв
✓ Watched
▶ 01:08:23
⏹ 01:10:05
01:42
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:42
«8100» и математический анализ списка
✓ Watched
▶ 01:10:06
⏹ 01:11:34
01:28
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:28
Разброс оценок у разных авторов
✓ Watched
▶ 01:11:35
⏹ 01:12:47
01:12
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:12
Реальные масштабы потерь по диссертациям
✓ Watched
▶ 01:12:48
⏹ 01:14:09
01:21
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:21
Контроль за изъятием и борьба с хищениями
✓ Watched
▶ 01:14:10
⏹ 01:15:39
01:29
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:29
Как искажение цифр меняет картину истории
✓ Watched
▶ 01:15:40
⏹ 01:17:44
02:04
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 02:04
База Свято-Тихоновского университета и сверка данных
✓ Watched
▶ 01:17:45
⏹ 01:20:46
03:01
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 03:01
Дело патриарха Тихона и приговоры ревтрибуналов
✓ Watched
▶ 01:20:47
⏹ 01:22:27
01:40
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:40
Критика историков за преувеличения
✓ Watched
▶ 01:22:28
⏹ 01:23:10
00:42
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:42
Исправление цифр в церковной историографии
✓ Watched
▶ 01:23:11
⏹ 01:24:06
00:55
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:55
Книга о патриархе Тихоне и оценка жертв 1922–1923
✓ Watched
▶ 01:24:07
⏹ 01:24:56
00:49
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:49
Как публикации автора меняют восприятие темы
✓ Watched
▶ 01:24:57
⏹ 01:26:52
01:55
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:55
Новый церковный учебник и корректировка оценок
✓ Watched
▶ 01:26:53
⏹ 01:27:49
00:56
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:56
Призыв к аудитории и финальная полемика
✓ Watched
▶ 01:27:50
⏹ 01:28:13
00:23
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:23
Завершение
URL
From To
Subtitle
Desc
url
cut from to
Subtitle
Fragment description