ПОМОГУТ ЛИ СТАЛИНСКИЕ МЕТОДЫ СЕЙЧАС? ОТВЕТ ИСТОРИКА | Дмитрий Верхотуров и Александр Колпакиди

2026-06-20

✓ Watched
▶ 00:00
⏹ 00:35
00:35
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:35
Александр Колпакиди представляет Дмитрия Верхотурова

✓ Watched
▶ 00:36
⏹ 02:02
01:26
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:26
книга “Казахский геноцид, которого не было”

✓ Watched
▶ 02:03
⏹ 02:44
00:41
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:41
Украина, Голодомор и враждебная историческая пропаганда

✓ Watched
▶ 02:45
⏹ 03:13
00:28
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:28
помогут ли сталинские методы сейчас

✓ Watched
▶ 03:14
⏹ 03:51
00:37
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:37
“Сталинский кристалл роста” и отсутствие Сталина в книге

✓ Watched
▶ 03:52
⏹ 04:38
00:46
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:46
почему нельзя говорить о сталинской эпохе без Сталина и строя

✓ Watched
▶ 04:39
⏹ 05:56
01:17
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:17
Госплан раннего периода и Госплан позднего СССР

✓ Watched
▶ 05:57
⏹ 07:01
01:04
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:04
математики в экономике и ошибка абстрактного подхода

✓ Watched
▶ 07:02
⏹ 07:59
00:57
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:57
технологии, производственные цепочки и реальные процессы

✓ Watched
▶ 08:00
⏹ 09:06
01:06
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:06
коллективизация в Казахстане и вооружённые восстания

✓ Watched
▶ 09:07
⏹ 10:40
01:33
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:33
конфликт советской власти с баями

✓ Watched
▶ 10:41
⏹ 11:43
01:02
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:02
сопротивление коллективизации по всей стране

✓ Watched
▶ 11:44
⏹ 12:30
00:46
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:46
НЭП как временная уступка

✓ Watched
▶ 12:31
⏹ 13:12
00:41
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:41
почему кооперативная альтернатива не спасла бы страну

✓ Watched
▶ 13:13
⏹ 13:59
00:46
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:46
коллективизация как план совхозизации сельского хозяйства

✓ Watched
▶ 14:00
⏹ 14:46
00:46
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:46
карта, МТС, элеваторы и военная логика организации колхозов

✓ Watched
▶ 14:47
⏹ 18:28
03:41
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 03:41
25-тысячники и люди, умеющие работать с техникой

✓ Watched
▶ 18:29
⏹ 19:57
01:28
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:28
тракторизация и реконструкция сельского хозяйства

✓ Watched
▶ 19:58
⏹ 20:47
00:49
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:49
сталинский метод как план, расчёт и ответственность

✓ Watched
▶ 20:48
⏹ 21:43
00:55
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:55
почему современные планы пишутся “чтобы были”

✓ Watched
▶ 21:44
⏹ 22:29
00:45
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:45
Балхаш, вода и трудности реальной индустриализации

✓ Watched
▶ 22:30
⏹ 23:34
01:04
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:04
миф о том, что индустриализацию сделали западные банкиры

✓ Watched
▶ 23:35
⏹ 24:05
00:30
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:30
почему сталинские методы сегодня не помогут автоматически

✓ Watched
▶ 24:06
⏹ 25:16
01:10
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:10
общество строителей и общество ждунов

✓ Watched
▶ 25:17
⏹ 26:26
01:09
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:09
армия мифов о советском опыте

✓ Watched
▶ 26:27
⏹ 26:59
00:32
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:32
Магнитка и её роль в победе

✓ Watched
▶ 27:00
⏹ 27:50
00:50
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:50
послевоенное восстановление как второй рывок

✓ Watched
▶ 27:51
⏹ 29:22
01:31
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:31
“Госплан” как вечная мантра без результата

✓ Watched
▶ 29:23
⏹ 30:23
01:00
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:00
приватизация квартир и соучастие общества в 90-х

✓ Watched
▶ 30:24
⏹ 31:07
00:43
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:43
почему приватизационное сознание мешает революционности

✓ Watched
▶ 31:08
⏹ 31:51
00:43
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:43
критика идеи “безналичного рубля”

✓ Watched
▶ 31:52
⏹ 33:02
01:10
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:10
чудо-фантики вместо реального производства

✓ Watched
▶ 33:03
⏹ 34:46
01:43
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:43
царские ценности и служилое государство

✓ Watched
▶ 34:47
⏹ 35:40
00:53
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:53
государство службы и русская мобилизационная традиция

✓ Watched
▶ 35:41
⏹ 37:30
01:49
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:49
зона ответственности как основа старого служилого общества

✓ Watched
▶ 37:31
⏹ 38:14
00:43
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:43
сталинские методы против социальных пороков

✓ Watched
▶ 38:15
⏹ 40:19
02:04
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 02:04
идеологическая борьба на оккупированных территориях

✓ Watched
▶ 40:20
⏹ 41:08
00:48
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:48
культ науки как основа советского рывка

✓ Watched
▶ 41:09
⏹ 43:23
02:14
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 02:14
СССР как позитивная альтернатива для народов

✓ Watched
▶ 43:24
⏹ 45:52
02:28
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 02:28
нацизм как дорога к национальной катастрофе

✓ Watched
▶ 45:53
⏹ 46:32
00:39
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:39
книга о Казахстане и метод системного анализа

✓ Watched
▶ 46:33
⏹ 47:28
00:55
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:55
“Бандеризация Украины” и раннее предупреждение

✓ Watched
▶ 47:29
⏹ 48:40
01:11
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:11
почему подкуп украинских элит оказался бесполезным

✓ Watched
▶ 48:41
⏹ 50:37
01:56
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:56
узкие специалисты и невозможность видеть систему целиком

✓ Watched
▶ 50:38
⏹ 51:32
00:54
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:54
сталинский опыт как источник уроков, включая ошибки

✓ Watched
▶ 51:33
⏹ 52:14
00:41
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:41
КПРФ и невнимание к исследователям советской экономики

✓ Watched
▶ 52:15
⏹ 53:07
00:52
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:52
интеллектуальная гегемония и рычаг партии

✓ Watched
▶ 53:08
⏹ 53:59
00:51
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:51
ВКП(б), НКВД и роль партии в войне

✓ Watched
▶ 54:00
⏹ 55:26
01:26
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:26
почему забывают вклад коммунистов в Победу

✓ Watched
▶ 55:27
⏹ 56:14
00:47
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:47
Иран как пример организованного государства

✓ Watched
▶ 56:15
⏹ 57:12
00:57
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:57
где искать современных системных исследователей

✓ Watched
▶ 57:13
⏹ 59:01
01:48
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:48
Островский, работа с источниками и трудные авторы

✓ Watched
▶ 59:02
⏹ 01:00:22
01:20
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:20
Гровер Ферр и проект полного собрания сочинений

✓ Watched
▶ 01:00:23
⏹ 01:01:56
01:33
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:33
американские авторы, разоблачающие мифы о Сталине

✓ Watched
▶ 01:01:57
⏹ 01:02:14
00:17
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:17
финал и анонс разговора о Казахстане

URL
From To
Subtitle
Desc
url
cut from to
Subtitle
Fragment description