Дебаты: Александр Колпакиди и Евгений Михайлов | Украина: Большевизм или подход царей?

2026-10-22 · edited 2026-10-22

✓ Watched
▶ 00:00
⏹ 00:54
00:54
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:54
Введение
✓ Watched
▶ 00:55
⏹ 02:44
01:49
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:49
Война на Украине
✓ Watched
▶ 02:45
⏹ 05:30
02:45
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 02:45
Коррупция и ответственность
✓ Watched
▶ 05:31
⏹ 07:22
01:51
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:51
Царская Россия и украинский вопрос
✓ Watched
▶ 07:23
⏹ 12:17
04:54
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 04:54
Гражданская война и большевики
✓ Watched
▶ 12:18
⏹ 13:10
00:52
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:52
Ожидания и реальность
✓ Watched
▶ 13:11
⏹ 15:09
01:58
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:58
Политика большевиков и право нации на самоопределение
✓ Watched
▶ 15:10
⏹ 17:59
02:49
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 02:49
Признание Украинской Народной Республики
✓ Watched
▶ 18:00
⏹ 21:41
03:41
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 03:41
Советская национальная политика
✓ Watched
▶ 21:42
⏹ 22:47
01:05
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:05
Изменение политики перед войной
✓ Watched
▶ 22:48
⏹ 24:47
01:59
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:59
Политика царизма на Украине
✓ Watched
▶ 24:48
⏹ 25:43
00:55
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:55
Украинский сепаратизм и царское правительство
✓ Watched
▶ 25:44
⏹ 27:11
01:27
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:27
Политика украинизации и её последствия
✓ Watched
▶ 27:12
⏹ 28:11
00:59
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:59
Большевики и их борьба за территории
✓ Watched
▶ 28:12
⏹ 30:08
01:56
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:56
Поддержка иностранных держав и большевиков
✓ Watched
▶ 30:09
⏹ 33:05
02:56
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 02:56
Борьба с националистами и мобилизация
✓ Watched
▶ 33:06
⏹ 34:37
01:31
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:31
Последствия украинизации и современные проблемы
✓ Watched
▶ 34:38
⏹ 35:34
00:56
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:56
Шизофрения и крах СССР
✓ Watched
▶ 35:35
⏹ 38:17
02:42
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 02:42
Братство людей труда
✓ Watched
▶ 38:18
⏹ 42:39
04:21
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 04:21
Интернационализм и христианство
✓ Watched
▶ 42:40
⏹ 46:12
03:32
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 03:32
Политика интернационализма
✓ Watched
▶ 46:13
⏹ 46:53
00:40
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:40
Классовая природа общества
✓ Watched
▶ 46:54
⏹ 47:51
00:57
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:57
Проблемы миграции и межнациональных отношений
✓ Watched
▶ 47:52
⏹ 49:49
01:57
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:57
Потери в войнах и отношение к солдатам
✓ Watched
▶ 49:50
⏹ 51:20
01:30
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:30
Политика замещения и её последствия
✓ Watched
▶ 51:21
⏹ 53:00
01:39
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:39
Братство народов и прогресс
✓ Watched
▶ 53:01
⏹ 56:47
03:46
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 03:46
Экономические и национальные проблемы
✓ Watched
▶ 56:48
⏹ 58:05
01:17
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 01:17
Демографические и политические проблемы
✓ Watched
▶ 58:06
⏹ 59:02
00:56
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:56
Заключение и выводы
✓ Watched
▶ 59:03
⏹ 59:50
00:47
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:47
Эстония и НАТО
✓ Watched
▶ 59:51
⏹ 01:00:18
00:27
⚠️
YouTube is currently unavailable

The video cannot be loaded. This may be due to network restrictions or YouTube being blocked in your region.

0:00 / 00:27
Завершение дискуссии
URL
From To
Subtitle
Desc
url
cut from to
Subtitle
Fragment description